ConfigurationWAN1 – ADSL WAN2 – Ethernet DHCP

Firmware is 3.9.9.4_BT. 

Load Balance / Route Policy
Destination – Domain NamePolicy set to route to the following over WAN2 as preferred interface; *.apple.com, *.icloud.com, *.wetransfer.com, *.onedrive.com
And for this to fail back to WAN1 (since WAN2 is not always available).

Problem
Using traceroute to check, only traffic to wetransfer.com actually routes via WAN2.
I’ve tried clearing DNS caches on client machines, but that doesn’t work.
Also, WAN routing based on source IP works seamlessly.

I'd appreciate any ideas to fix this!

Looking further at this, using traceroute,

1 192.168.0.1 (192.168.0.1) 12.223 ms 3.565 ms 4.234 ms
2 172.20.10.1 6.933 ms
xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx 21.622 ms 22.292 ms

1st response is from the router’s LAN IP address
2nd responses are from firstly the WAN2 gateway and secondly from the WAN1 gateway. The subsequent responses are from the WAN1 route to the target.

That’s with the priority of the Policy set to 1, but that doesn’t seem to make a difference. The diagnostic rule checker on the router seems to skip the policy and use a lower one.