DrayTek UK Users' Community Forum

Help, Advice and Solutions from DrayTek Users

Dual Wan - SMTP

  • jamesfield
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • New Member
  • New Member
More
05 Dec 2008 09:04 #1 by jamesfield
Dual Wan - SMTP was created by jamesfield
I have a situation with a 2930 and two wan connections. One is ethernet, the other is a bridged ADSL.

Due to different ISP's the SMTP traffic has to go via the ADSL connection.

The load balancing rules only seem to operate as a preference, and if the DSL link fails, the SMTP gets routed to the ethernet wan and bounce backs occur.

Someone mentioned static route for the net block of the ISP, or a list of ISP mail server address range.
The drayteks config for static routes requires not only the wan interface, but a gateway IP.
Would this be the static IP we get from the ADSL bridge? also, what happens if the ADSL has a dynamic IP?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
07 Dec 2008 00:01 #2 by mpwox11
Replied by mpwox11 on topic Dual Wan - SMTP
I'm just about to install my first dual WAN solution using 2820 routers and wanted to ask the same question about different smtp servers.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
11 Dec 2008 16:40 #3 by mpwox11
Replied by mpwox11 on topic Dual Wan - SMTP
I've just had this battle.
If both WANs are on all the time (and why wouldn't they be if they are unlimited ADSLs), the Vigor2820 will use WAN2 for all outgoing traffic simply because this WAN is always up first. This is because the Vigor100 on it is keeping the port live. Then if your client server or PCs are trying to talk to the SMTP server of the other ISP (i.e. WAN1) then you're just going to get errors.
One way around it is to ask your ISPs if one of them can give you SSL access to their SMTP server. As this is authenticated, you can access it from anyway (i.e. the other ISP). I solved it that way. Just had to reconfigure the client's Outlooks and a fix in their Avast antivirus to stop it blocking the traffic and they were away.

However, I've since had this solution from SEG tech support:

"Vigor2820 can router SMTP traffic through the specific WAN interface
you want.
Go to WAN - Load balance policy. Click on Index number to setup the
load balance policy. It can be defined based on the Source address,
destination address and the Service type."

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
17 Dec 2008 12:46 #4 by louis-m
Replied by louis-m on topic Dual Wan - SMTP
yes but i'm sure that will only work if both wans are up.
when wan1 goes down, all traffic will go through wan2 which is what you want really.
now picture this (for mail servers only)
say a user is using ntl or something similar with a dynamic ip address as a backup. the rdns for that mail server will probably not be correct and spam filters & aol etc will bounce the mail, probably just for the fact of it being from a dynamic range.
the only true way to do it is to have the 2nd wan from a static range with the rdns entries setup.
you could use a smart host for the 2nd wan and setup routing costs to it for the second wan. i know how to do it through exchange but not sure about postfix etc.

2820 = 3.3.2_RC5
2950 = 3.2.4

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
17 Dec 2008 12:50 #5 by louis-m
Replied by louis-m on topic Dual Wan - SMTP
sorry, was thinking the user had an on site smtp server there!
maybe, they would be better using a hosting company which doesn't limit smtp traffic to their own network?

2820 = 3.3.2_RC5
2950 = 3.2.4

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • jamesfield
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • New Member
  • New Member
More
12 Jan 2009 10:13 #6 by jamesfield
Replied by jamesfield on topic Dual Wan - SMTP
Thanks for the info, I too contacted SEG, and they advised that the Vigor can't really force traffic into just one WAN or drop the packets if that wan is unavailable. It will always attempt the 2nd WAN if the first is down.

I got lucky with this install, as the 2nd WAN refuses the connection, forcing it to queue on the exchange server waiting for the correct WAN to become active.
Although the issue is solved, I would still like some info on how to use the Static route function

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: Sami