DrayTek UK Users' Community Forum
Help, Advice and Solutions from DrayTek Users
3910, v4.3.1 - High Availability in Hot Standby with WAN IP Aliases
- service_bb
- Topic Author
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 35
- Thank you received: 0
27 Jun 2022 07:58 #101305
by service_bb
3910, v4.3.1 - High Availability in Hot Standby with WAN IP Aliases was created by service_bb
Hi All,
I've opened a ticket with support but was wondering if anyone else had come across this.
We use High Availability in Hot-Standby mode and have several WAN IP Alias. We use load-balance routes/policies to present specific subnets/vlan's as a different WAN IP.
When we enable HA in Hot-Standby mode, our primary WAN IP continues to work perfectly but our load-balance routes/policies on the Alias IP's see frequent periods of packet loss. If we exclude the WAN settings and disable the WAN on the secondary/slave router then everything works perfectly.
From the findings above, my suspicion is that when in HA Hot-Standby Mode, the secondary/slave router is correctly disabling the main WAN IP but not correctly disabling the IP Aliases.
I think this started happening in the v4 firmware branches as I'm unable to reproduce this on the last stable v3.
Anyone else come across / able to reproduce?
Kind regards,
I've opened a ticket with support but was wondering if anyone else had come across this.
We use High Availability in Hot-Standby mode and have several WAN IP Alias. We use load-balance routes/policies to present specific subnets/vlan's as a different WAN IP.
When we enable HA in Hot-Standby mode, our primary WAN IP continues to work perfectly but our load-balance routes/policies on the Alias IP's see frequent periods of packet loss. If we exclude the WAN settings and disable the WAN on the secondary/slave router then everything works perfectly.
From the findings above, my suspicion is that when in HA Hot-Standby Mode, the secondary/slave router is correctly disabling the main WAN IP but not correctly disabling the IP Aliases.
I think this started happening in the v4 firmware branches as I'm unable to reproduce this on the last stable v3.
Anyone else come across / able to reproduce?
Kind regards,
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- service_bb
- Topic Author
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 35
- Thank you received: 0
28 Jun 2022 08:10 #101313
by service_bb
Replied by service_bb on topic Re: 3910, v4.3.1 - High Availability in Hot Standby with WAN IP Aliases
FWIW, we see the same on 4.3.1.1
Have provided further findings to Draytek Support overnight.
Have provided further findings to Draytek Support overnight.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- lordforbes
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 2
- Thank you received: 0
11 Sep 2022 22:55 #101737
by lordforbes
Replied by lordforbes on topic Re: 3910, v4.3.1 - High Availability in Hot Standby with WAN IP Aliases
Hi there
I'll have a go - we have a couple of 3910's in HA mode (hot standby) with several WAN Alias IP's. I need an outage (probably not until next week) to fail over and test this....I setup HA a couple of weeks ago and the thing that concerns me is I cant actually prove it's even sync'ed properly.
Does this look as it's supposed to? Basically I can only see one router (even though it thinks its sync'd successfully) with STABLE=YES, SYNC=READY ... but only the primary router shows, - there's no sign of the backup ... (and it's not pingable either). Is this as expected?
I'll have a go - we have a couple of 3910's in HA mode (hot standby) with several WAN Alias IP's. I need an outage (probably not until next week) to fail over and test this....I setup HA a couple of weeks ago and the thing that concerns me is I cant actually prove it's even sync'ed properly.
Does this look as it's supposed to? Basically I can only see one router (even though it thinks its sync'd successfully) with STABLE=YES, SYNC=READY ... but only the primary router shows, - there's no sign of the backup ... (and it's not pingable either). Is this as expected?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- keith_lin
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 1
- Thank you received: 0
13 Sep 2022 08:58 #101748
by keith_lin
Replied by keith_lin on topic Re: 3910, v4.3.1 - High Availability in Hot Standby with WAN IP Aliases
Hi there,
HA with WAN IP Alias issues has been fixed in the latest firmware (i.e. v3910 4.3.2 release)
HA with WAN IP Alias issues has been fixed in the latest firmware (i.e. v3910 4.3.2 release)
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Chris, Sami
Copyright © 2024 DrayTek